People respond less to the size of a gift than to the sense that it was meant for them. What a famous restaurant experiment teaches small businesses about personal gestures.
A customer orders a set of linen napkins from a small online shop. When the parcel arrives, there’s a handwritten note tucked inside: “Thanks, Priya. I hope these make your Sunday lunches feel special. Lindiwe.” Next to it is a small sachet of lavender that she didn’t order and wasn’t expecting.
It cost the shop owner perhaps two minutes and a few rand. Priya photographs the note, posts it to her Instagram story, and orders again three weeks later.
Most business owners sense that small gestures like this help. What’s less widely known is how specific the conditions are that make them work. A famous experiment in an American restaurant showed that the same gift, a humble after-dinner mint, could have very different effects depending on how it was given.
People respond less to the size of a gift than to the sense that it was meant for them.
The second mint
In 2002, David Strohmetz, Bruce Rind, Reed Fisher and Michael Lynn published a study in the Journal of Applied Social Psychology with a cheerful title: “Sweetening the Till.” They worked with waiting staff in a restaurant to test whether giving diners sweets with the bill affected how much they tipped.
Compared with diners who received no sweets, those given one mint each left tips around 3% higher. Two mints each raised tips by about 14%. The most interesting condition involved the same total number of mints but a different gesture: the server gave one mint, began to walk away, then turned back and offered a second, signalling that this extra was especially for these diners. In that condition, tips rose by around 23%.
The researchers linked the result to reciprocity, the deep-seated human tendency to want to return a favour. The influential psychologist Robert Cialdini later popularised the study as an example of how a gift that feels personal and unexpected has more effect than one that feels routine.
It’s worth keeping the study in proportion. It took place in a single US restaurant, where tipping norms are strong, with modest numbers of tables. The percentages are commonly repeated with slightly different details online. The broad lesson, though, is supported by much wider research on reciprocity: how a gesture is given matters as much as what is given.
A second, personal mint lifted tips far more than its value would suggest.
What makes a gesture work
The mint study and the wider research on reciprocity point to three qualities that turn a small gift into something customers remember.
It feels personal. A gesture addressed to this customer, by name or in response to something they said, lands very differently from a standard freebie given to everyone. The second mint worked because it appeared to single the diners out.
It’s unexpected. Something customers already expect, such as a loyalty stamp or a standard thank-you email, quickly becomes part of the background. A small surprise stands out precisely because it wasn’t promised.
It’s genuine. People are quick to sense when a gesture is a sales tactic in disguise. A handwritten note that thanks someone sincerely builds goodwill. One that ends with a discount code and a request for a five-star review may feel transactional.
There’s also an ethical line worth holding. Reciprocity is powerful, which is why it can be misused: free gifts designed to make people feel obliged to buy something they don’t need, or “free” trials designed to trap. The healthier aim is to express genuine appreciation and let any return come naturally.
INFOGRAPHIC GOES HERE
Same gift, different effect. Three simple panels from the mint study. One mint each: tips up about 3%. Two mints each: up about 14%. One mint, then a personal second mint: up about 23%. Beneath: Personal · Unexpected · Genuine. Caption: Strohmetz et al.
Small → Personal → Unexpected.
Small gestures, built into the routine
The challenge for a busy small business is making these gestures happen consistently without them becoming a script. One approach is to decide on a few low-cost, high-thought moments and build them into your routine: a handwritten note in every tenth order, a follow-up message a week after a big job to ask how things are going, a small extra for a customer’s birthday if they’ve shared it, or simply remembering a regular’s usual order.
Give your team permission to make small gestures too. A staff member who can offer a free coffee to a customer who’s had a rough morning, without needing to ask, can create the kind of moment people talk about for years.
A few questions can help:
- What small, personal touch could we add at the end of each purchase or job?
- Which of our current “extras” have become so routine that customers no longer notice them?
- Can our team make small gestures without needing permission?
- Do our thank-yous ever come with a sales pitch attached?
Which brings us back to Priya and her linen napkins. The lavender sachet and the handwritten note worked as a small, sincere signal that a real person had packed her order and hoped she’d enjoy it. That’s the second mint, translated for a small online shop: not more, just more personal.
Build a few thoughtful gestures into your routine so they actually happen.
One Like Research & Further Reading
- David B. Strohmetz, Bruce Rind, Reed Fisher and Michael Lynn, “Sweetening the Till: The Use of Candy to Increase Restaurant Tipping”, Journal of Applied Social Psychology 32(2), 2002. Figures as reported by ERE/Humetrics and other summaries.
- Robert B. Cialdini, Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion (various editions).