An empty shelf loses today’s sale. An overstocked shelf loses the money you could have spent on tomorrow’s.
A customer walks into a small hardware shop on a Saturday morning for a specific size of wall plug. It’s one of the shop’s bestsellers. The shelf is empty. The owner apologises: the order went in late, and the delivery is due on Tuesday. The customer nods, thanks him and drives to the hardware chain fifteen minutes away.
In the storeroom behind the counter sit four boxes of decorative door knockers, bought three years ago on a supplier’s recommendation, of which six have sold.
Most small retailers and product businesses will recognise both halves of this picture: running out of what customers actually want, while money sits tied up in things they don’t. It’s one of the quieter ways a business loses money, because neither problem appears as a single dramatic loss. One is a sale that never happened. The other is cash that can’t be used for anything else.
An empty shelf loses today’s sale. An overstocked shelf loses the money you could have spent on tomorrow’s.
What customers do when it’s not there
The most comprehensive research on this comes from Thomas Gruen, Daniel Corsten and Sundar Bharadwaj, who in 2002 combined 52 studies covering 29 countries and around 72,000 shoppers in grocery and consumer-goods retail. They found that, on average, 8.3% of the items shoppers were looking for were out of stock.
They also asked what shoppers did next. When faced with an empty shelf, 31% of consumers said they went to another store, 26% switched to a different brand, 19% chose another item from the same brand, 15% delayed the purchase and 9% didn’t buy at all. For the shop, the store-switchers and the non-buyers together represent sales lost outright, and the switchers have also just been given a reason to try a competitor.
Perhaps the most useful finding for small businesses was about cause. The researchers concluded that most out-of-stocks originated in the store itself, through late or inaccurate ordering and shelves not being refilled, rather than with suppliers. In other words, many are fixable with better habits rather than better suppliers.
The other side of the problem is too much stock. The retail consultancy IHL Group has estimated the global cost of what it calls inventory distortion, combining out-of-stocks and overstocks, at well over a trillion dollars a year. For a small business, the issue is more personal: every rand sitting in a slow-moving box is a rand that can’t pay a supplier, fund marketing or buy more of what sells.
When an item is out of stock, many shoppers buy elsewhere or don’t buy at all.
Know your vital few
In most product businesses, a small number of items account for a large share of sales. Inventory managers often use a simple method called ABC analysis to make that visible. Sort your products by how much revenue each brings in over, say, the past six months. The “A” items are the small group at the top that bring in the most. The “C” items are the long tail at the bottom that sell rarely.
The point of the exercise is to treat these groups differently. A items should almost never run out: check them more often, keep a sensible buffer, and set a clear reorder point, the stock level at which you automatically place a new order. C items deserve far less attention and far less money: order smaller quantities, stop reordering the slowest ones, and consider clearing old stock at a discount to free up cash and space.
This doesn’t require sophisticated software. A spreadsheet export from your till or accounting system is enough to get started. Many point-of-sale systems can also flag low stock automatically once you enter a reorder level for each product.
INFOGRAPHIC GOES HERE
Your vital few.
Know your vital few → Never run out of them → Stop over-ordering the rest.
A Monday-morning habit
Most stock problems come from habits rather than bad luck. Orders get placed when someone notices a gap, which is usually too late. Slow sellers get reordered because they always have been. Supplier suggestions get accepted without checking past sales. A short weekly routine can fix much of this.
Each Monday, check your A items against their reorder points and place any orders that are due. Once a month, look at what hasn’t sold in the past 90 days and decide whether to discount, return or stop reordering it. And before taking on any new product, ask what evidence suggests your customers will buy it, and start with a small quantity.
A few questions can help:
- Which 20 or so products bring in most of our sales, and do they ever run out?
- Do we have a reorder point for each of them, or do we order when someone notices?
- How much money is tied up in stock that hasn’t sold for three months?
- When a customer asks for something we don’t have, do we record it?
Which brings us back to the hardware shop, its empty wall-plug shelf and its unloved door knockers. Clearing the knockers at cost would free up enough cash to keep a healthy buffer of the shop’s top-selling items. The next Saturday customer would find what they came for, and they’d have one fewer reason to discover the chain store down the road.
A small number of products usually brings in most of the sales.
One Like Research & Further Reading
- Thomas W. Gruen, Daniel Corsten and Sundar Bharadwaj, Retail Out-of-Stocks: A Worldwide Examination of Extent, Causes and Consumer Responses (Grocery Manufacturers of America, 2002), as reported by Progressive Grocer and summarised by the authors in later work.
- IHL Group, inventory distortion estimates (2023), as cited in Pygmalios, State of Retail 2026.