Most strategies don’t fail in the thinking. They fade in the doing.
Every January, the partners of a small architecture practice book a day away from the office to plan the year. It’s a good day. They review what worked, agree three big priorities, sketch out a growth target and leave feeling energised. Someone types up the notes.
By June, the notes are in a folder nobody opens. One priority has made progress. One has been quietly overtaken by client work. The third, a new service line, has a half-finished brochure and no one quite in charge of it. The partners aren’t sure whether the strategy was wrong or whether they just didn’t do it.
That uncertainty is common, and it matters. If you can’t tell whether a plan failed because it was a bad plan or because it was never properly carried out, you can’t learn much from it. Research on larger companies suggests the gap between what plans promise and what actually gets delivered is wide, and most of it is lost in fairly ordinary places.
Most strategies don’t fail in the thinking. They fade in the doing.
The strategy-to-performance gap
In 2005, Michael Mankins and Richard Steele of the consultancy Marakon Associates published the results of a survey of senior executives at nearly 200 large companies worldwide in Harvard Business Review. They asked how much of the financial performance promised in their strategic plans their companies actually delivered.
The average answer was 63%. More than a third of executives put the figure below half. Mankins and Steele called the shortfall the strategy-to-performance gap.
The more useful part of the research was where executives said the missing value went. Some of it came from inadequate resources, but much was lost in surprisingly ordinary breakdowns: a strategy that was poorly communicated, actions required to carry it out that were never clearly defined, unclear accountability for who would execute what, inadequate monitoring of progress, and a lack of consequences for success or failure. Each is a failure of follow-through rather than of strategic thinking.
The study is two decades old, covers large companies and relies on executives’ own estimates, so the 63% figure shouldn’t be treated as precise. But the pattern of losses will sound very familiar to anyone who has run a small business, where the same people who set the strategy are also answering the phones, serving customers and chasing invoices.
Companies realised only about two-thirds of the value their strategies promised.
A small-business version of the rules
Mankins and Steele proposed seven rules for closing the gap. Several translate neatly to small businesses.
Keep it simple and concrete. Describe your strategy in plain language: what you will do this year, and just as importantly, what you won’t. “Grow the business” is a wish. “Win ten new commercial clients in Durban and stop taking residential jobs under R20,000” is a strategy someone can act on.
Make priorities explicit. If everything is a priority, nothing is. Choose no more than three, and rank them, so that when time is short everyone knows which one wins.
Turn each priority into defined actions with owners. Every priority needs a short list of specific next steps, each with a named person and a date. As we explored in Everyone’s Job Is Nobody’s Job, unclear ownership is one of the most reliable ways for good intentions to drift.
Discuss resources early. A plan that needs 20 hours a week of the owner’s time, when the owner has five spare, isn’t a plan. Agree up front what time and money each priority will get.
Monitor continuously. Don’t wait for next January. A short monthly check against the plan lets you spot drift early and decide whether to push harder, adjust or stop.
INFOGRAPHIC GOES HERE
Where strategy value leaks. A bucket labelled 100% of the strategy’s promise, with leaks dripping out through labelled holes: Poorly communicated · Actions not defined · No clear owner · Not enough resources · Progress not tracked · No consequences.
A clear plan → Clear priorities → Clear owners → Real results.
Strategy on one page
A practical way to apply all of this is to fit your year’s strategy onto a single page. At the top, one or two sentences on what you’re trying to achieve. Below that, no more than three ranked priorities. Under each, the next three actions, each with an owner and a date, plus the time or money it will need. At the bottom, the two or three numbers you’ll check each month to know whether it’s working.
Then put that page somewhere everyone sees it, and give it fifteen minutes at the start of a monthly meeting. Which actions are done? Which are stuck, and why? Is any priority being starved of time? The point isn’t to judge anyone. It’s to notice drift early enough to do something about it.
A few questions can help:
- Could everyone in the business name our top three priorities right now?
- Does each priority have specific actions, owners and dates?
- Have we given each priority the time and money it actually needs?
- When did we last check our progress against the plan?
Which brings us back to the architecture practice and its June folder. Their January thinking may well have been sound. What was missing was the thread connecting it to everyday work: a single page, three owners, a monthly check. With those in place, next June they’d know whether the new service line had failed as an idea, or simply never been given a proper chance.
Fit your strategy on one page, with owners and dates for the next actions.
One Like Research & Further Reading
- Michael C. Mankins and Richard Steele, “Turning Great Strategy into Great Performance”, Harvard Business Review 83(7), July–August 2005. Figures checked against CQI’s summary and Marakon’s own published research note.