Your price tells customers what to expect before they’ve seen anything else.
A talented wedding photographer has a problem. Her portfolio is beautiful, her reviews are glowing, but bookings are slow. Assuming she’s too expensive, she lowers her package from R18,000 to R14,000. Bookings don’t improve much. A few months later, she drops it again to R11,000. Now the enquiries she gets are mostly from couples comparing her with much cheaper photographers, haggling over every extra hour and asking whether she really needs a second shooter.
A friend in the industry tells her something she doesn’t want to hear. Couples planning a premium wedding were skipping her because her price made her look like a budget option.
Most small business owners think of price as a number customers compare. It is that. But a growing body of research suggests it’s also something more: a signal that shapes what people expect and, remarkably, how they experience what they buy.
Your price tells customers what to expect before they’ve seen anything else.
The $90 wine that cost $10
In 2008, researchers from Caltech and Stanford, led by Hilke Plassmann and Antonio Rangel, published a study in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. They asked 20 volunteers to taste a series of wines inside a brain scanner, each labelled with its supposed price. What the volunteers didn’t know was that some wines appeared twice with different prices. A wine that actually cost $90 was sometimes labelled $90 and sometimes $10. A $5 wine was sometimes labelled $5 and sometimes $45.
The volunteers consistently rated the same wine as more pleasant when they thought it was more expensive. More strikingly, the brain scans showed that increasing the price of a wine increased activity in the medial orbitofrontal cortex, an area of the brain associated with experienced pleasantness. The price didn’t only change what people said. It appeared to change what they experienced. When the same people tasted the wines weeks later without any price information, the effect disappeared.
As co-author Baba Shiv of Stanford explained at the time, the finding suggested price is not just a clue about quality but can shape the experience itself.
The usual caveats apply. The sample was small, the participants weren’t wine experts and didn’t pay for the wine, and tasting wine is a particular kind of experience. But the study fits a broader pattern in consumer research: people use price as a signal, and their expectations shape how they judge what they receive.
The same wine tasted better when people believed it was more expensive.
Price as a positioning decision
For small businesses, the lesson is less about raising prices and hoping customers enjoy things more, and more about treating price as a positioning decision as well as a calculation of costs plus margin. The number you charge tells customers where you sit in the market and what kind of experience to expect.
That has a few practical implications.
Price should match the promise. If everything else about your business, including your work, your presentation and your service, signals premium quality, a budget price can create confusion and attract the wrong customers. The opposite is also true: a high price without the experience to match quickly damages trust.
Cutting prices is rarely a neutral act. Lowering prices may bring in more price-sensitive customers, but it can also quietly reposition the business. As the wedding photographer found, it can make you invisible to the customers you most wanted.
Consistency matters. Frequent discounts teach customers that your full price isn’t real. Occasional, purposeful offers are different from constant markdowns.
There’s an ethical boundary too. Using a high price to suggest quality that isn’t there is misleading, and customers who feel deceived rarely return. The goal is for price, product and experience to tell the same honest story.
INFOGRAPHIC GOES HERE
Same wine, different price. Two identical wine glasses side by side. Left labelled $10, right labelled $90, with a small brain icon above the right glass glowing more brightly.
Price sets expectations → Expectations shape experience.
Setting prices with positioning in mind
Before your next price change, step back from the spreadsheet for a moment. Ask who you most want as customers, what they expect to pay for the kind of quality and experience you offer, and what your current price tells them about you. Look at the businesses your ideal customers also consider, and where you sit among them.
If your work is genuinely strong but your price sits at the bottom of the market, you may be signalling the wrong thing. A carefully tested price increase, perhaps for new customers first, alongside clearer evidence of quality such as portfolio, reviews and guarantees, can attract a different and often more appreciative kind of customer. If your price is at the top, make sure every part of the experience lives up to it.
A few questions can help:
- What does our price tell a new customer about our quality before they see anything else?
- Does our price match the rest of what customers experience, from our website to our service?
- Have repeated discounts taught customers not to trust our full price?
- Are we attracting the customers we want at our current price, or the ones we don’t?
Which brings us back to the wedding photographer and her falling prices. Raising her package back to R18,000, with a clear description of what’s included and a portfolio that shows why, might bring fewer enquiries. But they’d more likely come from couples who value what she does, and who see her price as a promise rather than a warning.
Treat price as a positioning decision, not just costs plus margin.
One Like Research & Further Reading
- Hilke Plassmann, John O’Doherty, Baba Shiv and Antonio Rangel, “Marketing actions can modulate neural representations of experienced pleasantness”, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 105(3), 2008.
- Stanford University news release, 15 January 2008, quoting Baba Shiv.