People can’t picture a percentage. They can picture a person.
A home-care agency’s website is full of impressive numbers. Over 12,000 visits a year. 98% client satisfaction. Carers with an average of eight years’ experience. Every figure is true and carefully presented.
Yet when the owner asks new clients what persuaded them to call, almost none mention the statistics. Several mention the same short page instead: a story, told by a daughter, about how a carer called Nomsa helped her father keep gardening after his stroke, and how he started laughing again.
It’s a pattern many businesses notice. Numbers feel credible and professional, so we lead with them. But when it comes to moving people to act, research suggests a single, specific story about one person can be far more powerful, and that adding statistics to the story can even weaken it.
People can’t picture a percentage. They can picture a person.
One girl or millions
In 2007, Deborah Small of the Wharton School, George Loewenstein of Carnegie Mellon University and Paul Slovic of Decision Research published a series of field experiments in Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes. Participants were given $5 for completing a survey and then invited to donate some of it to the charity Save the Children.
Some read about statistical victims: millions of people facing hunger in several African countries. Others read about an identifiable victim: Rokia, a seven-year-old girl from Mali, with her photograph. On average, people gave $2.38 to help Rokia but only $1.14 in response to the statistics.
The most surprising finding came when people received both: Rokia’s story plus the statistics about the wider problem. Donations fell to $1.43, lower than for Rokia alone. The researchers concluded that statistics encouraged a more analytical frame of mind, which dampened the sympathy that the personal story had created. As Small put it, it’s easy to override people’s feelings with statistical information, but not easy to add feelings where they aren’t.
The experiments concerned charitable giving, which is driven strongly by emotion, and the amounts were small. Business decisions often require some evidence too. But the broader point is well supported by research on how people process vivid versus abstract information: a concrete, human story is often what moves people from interest to action.
Adding statistics to a story can make people care less, not more.
Telling one story well
For small businesses, this suggests leading with people rather than numbers, especially in content meant to persuade.
Focus on one person. A single customer, named (with permission) and described specifically, is more powerful than “our clients” in general. What was their situation? What changed?
Make it concrete. Details make stories real: the father who wanted to keep gardening, the café owner whose fridge broke on a Friday night, the bride whose dress needed rescuing two days before the wedding.
Show the change. A good customer story has a before and after: a problem, what you did, and how life is different now.
Let the customer speak. Their words, in a short quote or video, carry more weight than your description of them.
Use numbers carefully. Statistics still have a role in building credibility, but consider keeping them separate from the emotional story, perhaps on a different part of the page, rather than piling them on top of it.
As we explored in Stop Telling Customers Your Story. Invite Them Into It., customers respond to stories they can see themselves in. Always get clear permission before sharing anyone’s story, and protect privacy where needed.
INFOGRAPHIC GOES HERE
Who gets the help? Three simple bars from the Rokia experiment. 14. 38. 43. Caption: Small, Loewenstein and Slovic (2007): a single identifiable person drew more than twice the giving of statistics, and adding statistics reduced it.
One person → One problem → One change that mattered.
Finding your stories
Most businesses are surrounded by stories they never tell. Ask your team to share one customer moment each month that made them proud: a problem solved, a difference made, a thank-you that stuck. Ask happy customers whether they’d be willing to share their experience, in their own words. Choose the ones with a clear before and after, and the most specific details.
Then put those stories where they’ll have the most impact: near the top of your home page, on service pages, in proposals and in social posts. Keep your impressive figures, but let the stories do the persuading.
A few questions can help:
- Which customer’s story best captures what we do?
- Do our website and proposals lead with numbers or with people?
- What specific details would make our stories feel real?
- Have we asked customers for permission to share their experiences?
Which brings us back to the home-care agency and its impressive statistics. The numbers showed the agency was established and capable. But it was Nomsa, a carer, and a father back in his garden that made families pick up the phone. Building the website around a handful of stories like that, with the statistics in a supporting role, would let the agency’s real strength come through: the difference it makes to one family at a time.
Most businesses are surrounded by stories they never tell.
One Like Research & Further Reading
- Deborah A. Small, George Loewenstein and Paul Slovic, “Sympathy and callousness: The impact of deliberative thought on donations to identifiable and statistical victims”, Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 102(2), 2007. Summarised by Stanford Graduate School of Business.