When people aren’t sure what to choose, they look at what people like them have chosen.
A gym wants more members to sign up for its annual plan instead of paying month to month. Its first promotion lists the benefits: save 20%, lock in your price, free fitness assessment. A handful of people switch.
The following month, the manager adds one line to the sign-up page: “Most of our members choose the annual plan.” It’s true; just over half do. Switches to annual roughly double.
Nothing about the offer changed. The only difference was telling people what others like them had already chosen. It’s one of the most dependable effects in behavioural science, and one of the most underused in small-business promotion.
When people aren’t sure what to choose, they look at what people like them have chosen.
The hotel towel experiment
In 2008, Noah Goldstein, Robert Cialdini and Vladas Griskevicius published a study in the Journal of Consumer Research that has become a classic. Working with a hotel, they tested different cards asking guests to reuse their towels.
The standard card used an environmental message, asking guests to help protect the environment by reusing towels. A second card used a social norm: it told guests that the majority of guests at the hotel had reused their towels at least once during their stay. Guests who saw the social-norm message reused their towels noticeably more often, around 44%, compared with around 35% for the standard environmental message.
In a follow-up experiment, the researchers made the norm even more specific: the majority of guests who had stayed in this particular room had reused their towels. That produced the highest reuse rate of all, around 49%, even though the room number is objectively irrelevant. The closer the comparison group felt to the guest, the stronger the effect.
The findings are part of a large body of research by Cialdini and others on social proof: people’s tendency to look to others’ behaviour when deciding what to do, especially when they’re uncertain. The towel study has been widely replicated in spirit, though later studies show the size of the effect varies, and social norms work best when they’re true, relevant and specific.
The closer the comparison group felt to the guest, the stronger the effect.
Using social proof in promotion
Small businesses can use social proof in many honest, low-cost ways.
Name the popular choice. “Our most popular package”, “what most first-time customers order” or “the plan most members choose” helps hesitant customers decide, as long as it’s true.
Make the group relevant. The towel study showed that the more similar the comparison group, the stronger the effect. “Most families in Fourways choose our weekly service” is more persuasive than “thousands of customers love us”.
Use real numbers and real voices. “Over 300 local homes cleaned this year” and genuine reviews from named customers carry far more weight than vague claims. As we explored in Your Best Reviews Might Be Too Old to Count, recent, specific reviews matter.
Show it at the moment of decision. Social proof works best where customers are choosing: next to the booking button, on the pricing page, on the product itself.
Avoid negative norms. Messages like “Many customers forget to book their annual service” can backfire, because they tell people that forgetting is normal. Highlight what most people do right instead.
Never invent it. Fake reviews, invented customer counts or misleading “most popular” labels are dishonest and, in many countries including South Africa, can fall foul of consumer protection and advertising rules.
INFOGRAPHIC GOES HERE
Which message works best? Three hotel cards with towel-reuse rates. “Help save the environment”: about 35%. “Most guests reuse their towels”: about 44%. “Most guests who stayed in this room reuse their towels”: about 49%.
Uncertain customer → What people like me chose → An easier decision.
Finding your social proof
Start with your own data. What do most customers choose? Which package, product or service is most popular? How many customers have you served in your area this year? What do your best reviews say? These true facts are your raw material.
Then add a single line of social proof at your most important decision points: the pricing page, the booking form, the product page, the quote. Keep it specific and relevant to the customer reading it. Test whether it changes what people choose.
A few questions can help:
- What do most of our customers choose, and do we tell new customers that?
- Which comparison group would feel most similar to our typical customer?
- Where do customers hesitate, and could social proof help there?
- Are all our social-proof claims true and up to date?
Which brings us back to the gym and its annual plan. The benefits listed in the first promotion were real, but they asked people to make a decision alone. One honest sentence about what most members had already chosen made the decision feel safer and more normal. That’s social proof at its simplest: helping people see that others like them have already made the choice, and been glad they did.
Never invent social proof. Use the true facts you already have.
One Like Research & Further Reading
- Noah J. Goldstein, Robert B. Cialdini and Vladas Griskevicius, “A Room with a Viewpoint: Using Social Norms to Motivate Environmental Conservation in Hotels”, Journal of Consumer Research 35(3), 2008. Percentages are approximate; confirm against the original paper and
- Robert B. Cialdini, Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion (various editions), general reference on social proof.