In AI search, being mentioned can matter as much as being clicked.
The owner of a small garden-design studio checks her website statistics and feels a jolt of alarm. Visits from Google are down by almost a third compared with last year. Yet enquiries are roughly the same, and several new clients mention that they “saw her name” in a Google answer before they searched for her directly.
She’s experiencing something many businesses are noticing. Search engines increasingly answer questions directly, with AI-generated summaries at the top of the page, so fewer people click through to websites. Traffic, the number marketers have watched for two decades, is becoming a less reliable sign of whether a business is actually being found.
Research from a US search marketing agency put numbers on the change. It showed a steep fall in clicks when AI summaries appeared, but also a clear advantage for businesses that the summaries cited.
In AI search, being mentioned can matter as much as being clicked.
What happened to clicks
Seer Interactive, a US digital marketing agency, has been tracking how Google’s AI Overviews, the AI-generated summaries at the top of many search results, affect clicks. In an update published in September 2025, covering more than 3,000 search queries from June 2024 to September 2025, it found that for informational queries showing an AI Overview, the share of people clicking on an organic result dropped 61%, from 1.76% to 0.61%. Clicks on paid ads for those queries fell by 68%.
Even on queries without AI Overviews, organic click-through rates had fallen by around 41% over the year, suggesting people are increasingly finding answers elsewhere, including in AI chat tools and social platforms.
There was a notable bright spot. Brands cited within the AI Overview earned 35% more organic clicks and 91% more paid clicks than brands that weren’t cited for the same kinds of queries. Seer was careful to note that it couldn’t prove the citation caused those extra clicks; brands with stronger reputations may simply be more likely to be cited and clicked.
This was one agency’s analysis of its clients’ data, mainly in the US and focused on informational searches, and other studies have produced different figures. But together with the Pew Research Center findings explored in When Google Answers for You, it points in a consistent direction: fewer clicks overall, and more value in being part of the answer.
Traffic is becoming a less reliable sign of whether a business is actually being found.
New measures of visibility
If website traffic tells only part of the story, small businesses need a broader set of measures to understand whether search is working for them.
Enquiries and sales, not just visits. The ultimate measure is whether people get in touch and buy. Track enquiries by source and ask “how did you hear about us?”, including “saw you in a Google or AI answer” as an option.
Branded searches. If more people search for your business by name, your visibility is growing, even if fewer arrive through generic searches. As explored in The Free Metric That Hints at Your Future Sales, share of search is a useful signal.
Citations in AI answers. Regularly search for your main services, and ask AI assistants the questions your customers ask, noting whether your business is mentioned and how.
Google Business Profile activity. Calls, direction requests and website clicks from your profile often matter more for local businesses than website visits.
Quality of visitors. Fewer visitors who arrive better informed may convert at higher rates, as explored in Your Next Customer May Arrive via a Chatbot.
INFOGRAPHIC GOES HERE
Clicks are falling, citations matter. 61% (−61%). Beside it, a comparison: Brands cited in the AI Overview earned 35% more organic clicks than those not cited.
Fewer clicks → More mentions → New ways to measure.
Building a visibility check
Set up a simple monthly check alongside your usual website figures: enquiries by source, branded search trends, Google Business Profile actions and a quick test of whether your business appears in AI answers for your three or four most important customer questions. Over a few months, you’ll see a much fuller picture than traffic alone provides.
Then focus on what earns citations: specific, trustworthy, expert content, as explored in How to Become the Source AI Search Quotes, and a strong, consistent reputation across the web.
A few questions can help:
- Is our website traffic falling while enquiries hold steady, or are both falling?
- Do we ask new customers whether they found us through AI answers?
- Are we cited in AI summaries for our most important customer questions?
- Which measures beyond traffic should we track each month?
Which brings us back to the garden-design studio and its alarming traffic figures. Fewer people were clicking through, but her name was appearing in Google’s answers and clients were finding her anyway. By tracking enquiries, branded searches and AI citations alongside traffic, she could see that her visibility was holding up, and focus her energy on the content that kept her in those answers.
Track enquiries, branded searches and AI mentions, not just visits.
One Like Research & Further Reading
- Seer Interactive, “AIO Impact on Google CTR: September 2025 Update”, as reported by Search Engine Land.