Growth Usually Comes From More Customers, Not More Loyal Ones

Loyalty programmes reward the customers you already have. Growth usually needs the ones you don’t.

A neighbourhood coffee shop wants to grow. The owner reads that loyal customers are the key to success, so she launches a beautifully designed stamp card: buy nine coffees, get the tenth free. Her regulars love it. They collect stamps enthusiastically and redeem free coffees every couple of weeks.

Six months later, sales are almost exactly where they were. Her regulars were already coming in most mornings. The card rewarded them for doing what they’d have done anyway. Meanwhile, hundreds of people walking past each day still haven’t tried her coffee.

It’s a very common pattern. Many small businesses focus their growth efforts on making existing customers more loyal, because those customers are visible, friendly and easy to reach. But decades of research on how businesses grow suggest the bigger opportunity usually lies elsewhere: with people who don’t yet buy from you at all, or who buy only occasionally.

Loyalty programmes reward the customers you already have. Growth usually needs the ones you don’t.

Double jeopardy

In 1990, Andrew Ehrenberg, Gerald Goodhardt and Patrick Barwise published a paper in the Journal of Marketing called “Double Jeopardy Revisited”. Drawing on years of data about what people actually buy, they described a pattern found across many different product categories.

Smaller brands, they showed, suffer twice. In any given period, they have far fewer buyers than larger brands. And those buyers also tend to buy them slightly less often. Loyalty, in other words, doesn’t differ dramatically between big and small brands; the main difference is how many customers each one has. As the authors put it, the reverse pattern, a small brand with “few but exceptionally loyal buyers, has seldom if ever been reported.”

The pattern has since been replicated many times and is a central idea in Byron Sharp’s influential book How Brands Grow. Its main implication is that growth depends substantially on increasing a brand’s penetration, the number of people who buy it at all, rather than mainly on persuading existing customers to buy more.

The research comes mostly from repeat-purchase consumer categories, such as groceries and everyday goods, and there are exceptions, including niche brands with unusually devoted followings. Service businesses with long-term contracts may see different patterns. But for many small businesses, particularly shops, cafés and other repeat-purchase businesses, the lesson is a useful corrective to an exclusive focus on loyalty.

Bigger brands mostly have more customers, not much more loyal ones.

Growing your reach

If growth comes mainly from more customers, the practical question becomes: how do you reach more of the people who might buy from you, including those who buy only occasionally?

The Ehrenberg-Bass Institute frames this in terms of two kinds of availability.

Mental availability means being thought of when someone is in a buying situation. As we explored in Your Customers Probably Don’t Think You’re That Different, that depends on being remembered and recognised at the right moments, which usually means reaching a broad audience consistently rather than talking only to existing fans.

Physical availability means being easy to find and buy from: convenient opening hours, more places to buy, simpler online ordering, better visibility in search, or a presence at local markets and events.

Light and occasional buyers matter more than they seem. In most businesses, they make up a large share of the customer base. They may not show up every week, but collectively they often account for a significant share of sales, and they are where growth usually comes from.

None of this means ignoring existing customers. Looking after them well protects what you have, and a good experience leads to recommendations. But it does suggest balancing loyalty efforts with a deliberate push to reach new people.

INFOGRAPHIC GOES HERE

Where growth comes from. Two side-by-side shops. Left, labelled Loyalty focus: the same ten regular customers, each buying a little more. Right, labelled Reach focus: the same ten regulars plus thirty occasional customers who now know the shop exists.

Reach more people → Win more buyers → Grow.

Rebalancing your growth plan

Look at where your growth efforts currently go. How much time and money is spent on keeping existing customers buying, through loyalty cards, newsletters to current customers or special offers for regulars, compared with reaching people who haven’t bought from you yet? If the balance is heavily tilted towards existing customers, it may be worth shifting some effort outwards.

That might mean being visible in places new customers already go, partnering with neighbouring businesses, making it easier to buy for the first time, or extending opening hours to suit people who can’t currently reach you. It also means being patient: building awareness among a wider audience takes longer to pay off than a promotion to regulars, but it’s usually where the bigger gains lie.

A few questions can help:

Which brings us back to the coffee shop and its well-loved stamp card. Her regulars deserve their free coffee. But the growth she wanted was walking past her window every morning. A sandwich board with her best offer, a stall at the Saturday market and a quicker grab-and-go counter for commuters might have done more for her business than any number of stamps.

Loyalty schemes reward the customers you have. Growth needs the ones you don’t.

One Like Research & Further Reading

  1. Andrew S. C. Ehrenberg, Gerald J. Goodhardt and T. Patrick Barwise, “Double Jeopardy Revisited”, Journal of Marketing 54(3), 1990. Quote via The Repeat.
  2. Byron Sharp, How Brands Grow: What Marketers Don’t Know (Oxford University Press, 2010).

Popular Articles

Most Recent Posts

  • All Post
  • AI & Automation
  • Brand Development
  • Brand Foundation
  • Business Growth
  • Case Studies
  • Creative
  • Design Thinking
  • Digital
  • Discovery
  • Human Design
  • Insights
  • Lead Generation
  • Marketing
  • Strategy
    •   Back
    • AI Search & Discovery
    • AI Tools & Platforms
    • AI in Business
    • Prompting & Human Thinking
    • Automation & Workflows
    • Future of AI
    •   Back
    • Brand Psychology
    • Brand Experience
    • Brand Systems
    • Brand Value
    •   Back
    • Marketing Strategy
    • SEO, AEO & GEO
    • Content
    • Promotion
    • Channels
    • Performance
    •   Back
    • Human Thinking
    • Clarity
    • Innovation
    • UX & UI
    • Iteration
    •   Back
    • Trends
    • Consumer Behaviour
    • Ideas
    • Signals
    • Future Thinking
    •   Back
    • Direction
    • Positioning
    • Customer Insight
    • Growth
    • Decision-Making
    •   Back
    • Visibility
    • Startup Growth
    • Project Management
    • Systems
    • Operations
    • Execution
    •   Back
    • Marketing Discovery
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus luctus.

Products

Automated Chatbot

Data Security

Virtual Reality

Communication

Support

Services

FAQ's

Privacy Policy

Terms & Condition

Team

Contact Us

Company

About Us

Services

Features

Our Pricing

Latest News

© 2023 Created with Royal Elementor Addons

ChatGPT Prompts

About Us

Projects

Team Member

Experience

© 2026 One Like

Hello, I'm Naut!
Try our Prompt Generator to create ChatGPT workflows in seconds.