What Are Customers Really Hiring You to Do?

Customers hire what you sell to help them make progress in their lives.

The owner of a small neighbourhood gym believes his members are buying fitness. So his marketing talks about strength, cardio, the latest equipment and personal-best results. Membership is steady but not growing.

Then he starts asking members, over coffee after classes, why they actually come. The answers surprise him. A retired teacher says it’s the only place she talks to people most weekdays. A young father says the 5.30am class is the one hour of the day nobody needs anything from him. A woman recovering from an illness says she wanted somewhere she wouldn’t feel judged for starting slowly. Hardly anyone mentions the equipment.

They were all buying something from his gym. But for many of them, it wasn’t mainly fitness. It was company, calm or confidence. And that difference has big implications for how he should describe, design and sell what he offers.

Customers hire what you sell to help them make progress in their lives.

The milkshake story

The late Harvard Business School professor Clayton Christensen called this idea “jobs to be done”. He and his co-authors set it out in a 2016 Harvard Business Review article and in the book Competing Against Luck. The central idea is that people “hire” products and services to get a job done in a particular situation, and “fire” them when something else does the job better.

Christensen’s best-known illustration involved a fast-food chain that wanted to sell more milkshakes. It had tried the usual approach: asking customers what they wanted, then tweaking flavours, thickness and price. Nothing much changed. A researcher working with Christensen took a different approach. He spent a day in a restaurant watching who bought milkshakes, when, and what else they did. He noticed that a large share were bought early in the morning by people alone, who drove off with them. The next morning, he interviewed customers who left with milkshake in hand, asking what job they had hired it to do.

The answer was that many commuters faced a long, dull drive and wanted something to keep them occupied and full until lunch. A milkshake did that job better than a banana, a doughnut or a bagel: it lasted, it was easy to hold and it didn’t make a mess. Their real competitors weren’t other milkshakes. They were boredom and hunger on the morning commute.

The story is an illustrative consulting case rather than a controlled study, and retellings vary in their details. But it has shaped how many businesses think about customers, because it shows how asking the wrong question, “what do you want in a milkshake?”, can hide what really matters.

People don’t simply buy products. They hire them to make progress.

Finding the real job

Christensen and his co-authors argued that jobs have three dimensions, and the most important ones are often the least obvious.

Functional. The practical task: get fit, fix the leak, file the tax return.

Emotional. How the customer wants to feel: calm, confident, in control, less anxious.

Social. How they want to be seen: a capable parent, a professional who has things handled, a good host.

The gym owner had focused entirely on the functional job. His members were often hiring him for emotional and social ones: connection, a moment of peace, a place to rebuild confidence without judgement.

Uncovering these jobs usually means asking different questions. Instead of “What features do you want?”, ask about the situation and the moment of decision. When did you first realise you needed something like this? What were you using or doing before? What nearly stopped you from buying? What would you do if we disappeared tomorrow? As we explored in Why Design Thinking Works, When It Works, asking about real past experiences is far more reliable than asking people to predict what they’d want.

INFOGRAPHIC GOES HERE

The three sides of a job. Three overlapping circles labelled Functional (“Get fitter”), Emotional (“Feel calm and in control for an hour”), Social (“Be part of a friendly group”). At the centre: The job the customer is hiring you for.

Functional job → Emotional job → Social job.

Putting the job to work

Talk to five to ten recent customers and five who considered you but chose someone else. Ask about the circumstances that led them to look in the first place, what alternatives they considered, including doing nothing, and what made them choose. Listen for the moment of struggle that pushed them to act, and the emotional or social progress they hoped to make.

Then look at your business through that lens. Does your marketing describe the job customers are hiring you for, or just your features? Are there parts of your offer that do the job particularly well, and could you strengthen them? Who or what are you really competing with? For the gym, it might be the sofa, a walking group or a café, as much as the gym down the road.

A few questions can help:

Which brings us back to the gym owner and his surprising coffee conversations. Rewriting his marketing around a friendly community, a peaceful early-morning hour and a judgement-free place to start would speak directly to the jobs his members were already hiring him to do. The equipment would still matter. It just wouldn’t be the headline any more.

Ask what was happening in a customer’s life when they started looking.

One Like Research & Further Reading

  1. Clayton M. Christensen, Taddy Hall, Karen Dillon and David S. Duncan, “Know Your Customers’ ‘Jobs to Be Done’”, Harvard Business Review, September 2016, and Competing Against Luck (HarperBusiness, 2016).
  2. Harvard Business School Working Knowledge, “Clay Christensen’s Milkshake Marketing”.

Popular Articles

Most Recent Posts

  • All Post
  • AI & Automation
  • Brand Development
  • Brand Foundation
  • Business Growth
  • Case Studies
  • Creative
  • Design Thinking
  • Digital
  • Discovery
  • Human Design
  • Insights
  • Lead Generation
  • Marketing
  • Strategy
    •   Back
    • AI Search & Discovery
    • AI Tools & Platforms
    • AI in Business
    • Prompting & Human Thinking
    • Automation & Workflows
    • Future of AI
    •   Back
    • Brand Psychology
    • Brand Experience
    • Brand Systems
    • Brand Value
    •   Back
    • Marketing Strategy
    • SEO, AEO & GEO
    • Content
    • Promotion
    • Channels
    • Performance
    •   Back
    • Human Thinking
    • Clarity
    • Innovation
    • UX & UI
    • Iteration
    •   Back
    • Trends
    • Consumer Behaviour
    • Ideas
    • Signals
    • Future Thinking
    •   Back
    • Direction
    • Positioning
    • Customer Insight
    • Growth
    • Decision-Making
    •   Back
    • Visibility
    • Startup Growth
    • Project Management
    • Systems
    • Operations
    • Execution
    •   Back
    • Marketing Discovery
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus luctus.

Products

Automated Chatbot

Data Security

Virtual Reality

Communication

Support

Services

FAQ's

Privacy Policy

Terms & Condition

Team

Contact Us

Company

About Us

Services

Features

Our Pricing

Latest News

© 2023 Created with Royal Elementor Addons

ChatGPT Prompts

About Us

Projects

Team Member

Experience

© 2026 One Like

Hello, I'm Naut!
Try our Prompt Generator to create ChatGPT workflows in seconds.