Your brand colour describes your personality before you’ve said a word about it.
Two accountants leave a large firm to start their own practice. They want to look different from the stiff, grey corporate world they’ve left behind, so they choose a vivid orange as their brand colour: energetic, fun, unexpected. Their website, cards and signage all burst with it.
A few months in, a prospective client mentions, kindly, that the brand made her wonder whether they were a marketing agency. Another says it felt “a bit playful” for someone she’d trust with her tax return. The accountants are good at what they do. Their colour just seemed to be telling a different story.
Most people choose brand colours based on personal taste, what competitors aren’t using or what looks good on a screen. Those are reasonable starting points. But research on colour in marketing suggests that colours also carry associations with personality traits, and that those associations can quietly shape what customers expect from a business.
Your brand colour describes your personality before you’ve said a word about it.
Colour and brand personality
In 2012, Lauren Labrecque of Northern Illinois University and George Milne of the University of Massachusetts Amherst published four studies in the Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science under a memorable title: “Exciting red and competent blue”. They noted that, despite how heavily marketers rely on colour, there had been surprisingly little academic research into how it shapes brand perceptions.
Using logos for fictional brands, so that people had no prior associations, they mapped colours onto the dimensions of brand personality commonly used in marketing research: sincerity, excitement, competence, sophistication and ruggedness. As the title suggests, red was linked with excitement and blue with competence. Other associations included white and pink with sincerity, black and purple with sophistication, and brown with ruggedness.
They also found that saturation and value mattered, not just hue. Saturation is how vivid a colour is; value is how light or dark it is. More saturated colours tended to amplify excitement and a sense of strength, while lighter, softer shades felt calmer and more sincere. In further studies, changing a brand’s colour shifted perceptions of its personality and influenced purchase intentions and how likeable and familiar the brand seemed.
Colour associations aren’t universal laws. They are learned, they vary between cultures and contexts, and they interact with everything else about a brand. But the research suggests colour is a meaningful signal, not just decoration.
Colours shape whether customers see a brand as sincere, exciting, competent or sophisticated.
Choosing and using colour well
For small businesses, the research suggests a few practical principles.
Start with personality, not preference. Decide which two or three qualities you most want customers to sense: trustworthy and capable, warm and sincere, bold and exciting, refined and sophisticated. Then choose colours that support those qualities, rather than the owner’s favourite.
Use saturation and lightness deliberately. The same hue can feel very different depending on how vivid or soft it is. A deep, muted orange can feel warm and grounded; a bright neon orange feels loud and energetic. The accountants might have kept a touch of warm orange as an accent, paired with a confident navy, to signal both approachability and competence.
Consider your sector and your customers. Some associations are strongly shaped by context and culture. Colours carry different meanings in different communities, and some have strong associations with sports teams, political parties or religious traditions. Test your choices with real customers rather than assuming.
Be consistent. Once chosen, colour becomes one of the most recognisable parts of a brand. As we explored in A Brand System Is a Recipe, Not a Rulebook, consistent use is what turns a colour into a distinctive asset. And as The Customers Your Brand Can’t See explained, your palette must also offer enough contrast to be readable.
A word of caution: you’ll often see precise claims online, such as colour “increasing brand recognition by 80%”. These are widely repeated but rarely traceable to solid research. Treat them sceptically.
INFOGRAPHIC GOES HERE
Colour and personality. Five columns based on brand personality dimensions. Sincerity: white, soft pink, light yellow. Excitement: red, orange. Competence: blue. Sophistication: black, purple. Ruggedness: brown, earthy tones.
Personality first → Colour second → Consistency always.
Testing your palette
A simple test can reveal whether your colours are doing their job. Show your logo or a key page of your website to a handful of people who don’t know your business, ideally people who resemble your customers. Ask them to describe the personality of the business in three words, and what kind of company they imagine it to be. If their answers don’t match what you intended, your colours may be telling a different story.
If a change seems necessary, it rarely needs to be dramatic. Adjusting saturation, adding a supporting colour or changing which colour dominates can shift the feel considerably while keeping some continuity for existing customers.
A few questions can help:
- Which two or three personality traits do we most want customers to sense?
- Do our main colours tend to suggest those traits, or something else?
- How vivid or soft are our colours, and does that suit our personality?
- Have we tested our colours with real customers, rather than relying on taste?
Which brings us back to the accountants and their bright orange. They didn’t need to become grey and corporate. A confident navy for the main brand, with a warm orange accent for highlights and calls to action, could signal both the competence clients look for in an accountant and the approachable, modern personality that made them start their own practice in the first place.
Ask strangers to describe your brand from your colours alone.
One Like Research & Further Reading
- Lauren I. Labrecque and George R. Milne, “Exciting red and competent blue: the importance of color in marketing”, Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science 40(5), 2012.