Promotions bring sales forward. Brand building makes future sales easier.
A homeware shop runs a promotion almost every week. Twenty per cent off cushions. Buy two candles, get one free. Flash sale on Friday. Each promotion produces a satisfying spike in sales, and the owner can see exactly what it delivered.
But over two years, something has shifted. Customers rarely buy at full price any more; they wait for the next deal. Margins have shrunk. And when the owner asks a few regulars what the shop is known for, the most common answer is “good sales”.
None of the promotions was a mistake on its own. Together, they had quietly turned the business into one that customers associate with discounts rather than with anything distinctive. It’s a common pattern, and some of the most influential research in marketing explains why it happens and how to avoid it.
Promotions bring sales forward. Brand building makes future sales easier.
The long and the short of it
In 2013, Les Binet and Peter Field published a report for the UK’s Institute of Practitioners in Advertising (IPA) called The Long and the Short of It. They analysed 996 marketing campaigns entered into the IPA Effectiveness Awards between 1980 and 2010, looking at what kinds of activity produced the largest business effects over time.
They distinguished between two kinds of marketing. Sales activation, such as promotions, discounts and direct-response ads, produces quick, measurable spikes in sales that fade within weeks. Brand building, which aims to make a business more memorable, liked and distinctive, works more slowly but its effects last and grow. Critically, Binet and Field found that the benefits of brand building, including the ability to charge more without losing customers, take time to show: at least six months before pricing effects start to appear, and they were still growing after three years.
Their best-known recommendation was a balance. On average across categories, campaigns achieved the strongest results when about 60% of the marketing budget went into brand building and about 40% into sales activation. Too much activation delivered short-term spikes but weaker long-term growth; too little meant missing the near-term sales that keep a business going.
The research has limits. It was based on large-company campaigns entered for effectiveness awards, so it skews towards successful, well-funded brands, and the 60:40 split is an average that varies by sector. Later work found business-to-business brands tended to need relatively more activation. But the principle has been widely replicated in practice: a business that only ever promotes tends to erode the very brand that makes promotion unnecessary.
Campaigns that balanced brand building with activation produced the strongest long-term results.
What brand building looks like for a small business
For a small business, “brand building” can sound like something only big companies with television budgets can afford. In practice, it simply means activity whose main job is to make you more memorable, liked and distinctive to the people who might buy from you in future, rather than to trigger a sale today.
That might include:
- Consistent, recognisable content that shows what you stand for, such as the work you do, the people behind it and the values you hold.
- Community presence, such as sponsoring a local team, hosting an event or being part of the neighbourhood in visible ways.
- Useful expertise shared freely: advice, guides and answers to common questions that build trust over time.
- Distinctive assets used consistently: your colours, style, tone and characters, as we explored in A Brand System Is a Recipe, Not a Rulebook.
- Reaching new people, not just existing customers. As Growth Usually Comes From More Customers showed, broad reach matters.
Sales activation still has its place: a seasonal sale, a launch offer, a clear call to book. The goal is balance, not abandoning promotions.
INFOGRAPHIC GOES HERE
Two kinds of marketing over time. A line chart over three years. Sales activation: sharp spikes that drop back quickly. Brand building: a slower line that rises steadily and keeps rising.
Promotions → Sales now. Brand building → Easier sales later.
Rebalancing your marketing
Look back at the past six months of marketing: posts, adverts, emails, events, offers. Roughly sort each activity into one of two piles. Was its main purpose to generate sales now, or to make the business more memorable and distinctive over time? If almost everything sits in the first pile, your brand may be quietly running down.
You don’t need to hit an exact 60:40 split. The point is direction. Gradually shift some effort towards activity that builds memory and preference, and judge it over a longer time frame. Brand building rarely shows up in this week’s sales figures, so it needs patience, and ideally a few longer-term measures, such as how many people search for you by name, how many enquiries come from recommendations, and whether you can hold your prices.
A few questions can help:
- What share of our marketing is designed to drive sales this week, and what share builds the brand for next year?
- Are customers waiting for our next discount before they buy?
- What would people say our business is known for, beyond price?
- How will we measure brand building over months, not days?
Which brings us back to the homeware shop known for “good sales”. Cutting back the weekly promotions and putting some of that effort into telling the story behind its products, hosting styling evenings and building a recognisable look across everything it shares might feel slow at first. But over a year or two, it could build the kind of brand customers are happy to pay full price for.
If almost everything you do is a promotion, you’re borrowing from future sales.
One Like Research & Further Reading
- Les Binet and Peter Field, The Long and the Short of It: Balancing Short and Long-Term Marketing Strategies (Institute of Practitioners in Advertising, 2013). Summarised in Peter Field, “A matter of time”, Campaign, and the IPA’s presentation.