Most competitor research ends in a copycat shopping list. Four lenses and a one-afternoon exercise for finding the gap your competitors leave open.
Most competitor research follows a familiar pattern. Someone opens five rival websites in five tabs, scrolls through each one with growing unease, and closes the laptop with a shopping list. They’ve got a chatbot. They’re offering free delivery. They post reels every day. Their homepage has a video of people laughing in an office. Should we have one of those?
It feels like research, and in a way it is. But it usually answers the wrong question. It tells you what your competitors are doing, when the more useful question is what their customers are still not getting.
Competitor research is one of the five areas of discovery in The Marketing Discovery Framework, alongside the customer, the market, the numbers and what’s happening inside the business. Done well, it’s one of the cheapest sources of insight a small business has. Done badly, it’s how a whole industry ends up looking exactly the same.
Why copying feels safe, and where it leads
Copying a competitor feels sensible because it seems to come with evidence attached. If they’re doing it, surely it works? In reality, you rarely know whether it works. You only know they’re doing it. That chatbot might be ignored by every visitor. The daily reels might be a junior marketer’s best guess. You’d be inheriting their assumptions, not their results.
There’s a bigger cost too. Harvard Business School professor Youngme Moon, in her book Different: Escaping the Competitive Herd, argues that the very act of watching competitors closely pushes businesses towards sameness. “Competitive pressure, I argue, breeds conformity,” she told HBS Working Knowledge. Everyone matches everyone else’s features and offers, until “the differences between them start to become increasingly trivial”.
You can see this on almost any high street or search results page. Every plumber is “reliable and affordable”. Every accountant offers “peace of mind”. Every café has the same flat white, the same Edison bulbs, the same reclaimed wood. Nobody chose to be forgettable. They just kept looking sideways instead of looking at the customer.
“Competitive pressure, I argue, breeds conformity.” — Youngme Moon, Harvard Business School
What to look for instead
Good competitor research is less about what rivals have and more about what they reveal: about the market, about customers, and about the space nobody is standing in yet. Four lenses help.
| Lens | The question | Where to look | What it can reveal |
|---|---|---|---|
| Promises | What does everyone claim? | Homepages, taglines, ads, Google Business profiles | Claims so common they’ve stopped meaning anything, and the one nobody is making |
| Complaints | What frustrates their customers? | Two- and three-star reviews, social comments, community groups | Problems you could solve better, in your customers’ own words |
| Gaps | Who are they ignoring? | Who their imagery, pricing and packages are built for | Customers who feel overlooked by the whole category |
| Silences | What does nobody talk about? | Pricing pages, FAQs, terms, timelines | Topics customers worry about that the industry avoids, like price, delays or guarantees |
The complaints lens is the most underrated. One-star reviews are often rants and five-star reviews are often polite. The two- and three-star reviews tend to be the most thoughtful, because they come from people who wanted to like the business but were let down by something specific. Read twenty of them across your competitors and patterns appear quickly.
The silences lens is the most surprising. If no one in your industry publishes prices, explains how long things take or says what happens when something goes wrong, that silence is an opportunity. Being the first to talk openly about the awkward thing can be more distinctive than any new feature.
Promises → Complaints → Gaps → Silences.
A one-afternoon competitor discovery exercise
You don’t need expensive software for this. You need a few hours, a spreadsheet or notebook, and the discipline to write down what you find before deciding what to do about it.
- Pick five competitors. Three obvious ones, one that’s bigger than you, and one that solves the same problem in a completely different way. A gym’s competitors include other gyms, but also running clubs, YouTube workouts and the couch.
- Copy out their main promise. Just the headline or tagline from each homepage, side by side. Circle the words that appear more than once.
- Read twenty middling reviews. Spread them across the five. Note every specific frustration, using the customer’s own words.
- Note who’s missing. Look at the photos, examples and package names. Who would feel unwelcome or unrepresented?
- List what nobody says. Price, timelines, guarantees, what happens after the sale.
- Write one sentence. “Customers in our market are still frustrated by … and nobody is …” That sentence is your discovery. The tactics come later.
It’s worth doing this twice a year. Markets shift, competitors change, and what was a gap last spring might be crowded by summer.
Don’t ask what competitors have that you don’t. Ask what their customers are still waiting for.
Look past them, not at them
Those five open tabs aren’t the problem. Looking at competitors is one of the most useful things a small business can do. The trick is changing what you’re looking for. Instead of asking “what have they got that we haven’t?”, ask “what are their customers still waiting for?”
The first question leads to a shopping list and, eventually, a market where everyone looks the same. The second leads somewhere far more interesting: a gap with your name on it. Your competitors have already done a lot of free research for you. You just have to read it from the customer’s side of the counter.
One Like Research & Further Reading
- When Other Companies Compete Like Crazy, Dare to Be Different, Harvard Business School Working Knowledge, 26 April 2010 (interview with Youngme Moon on Different: Escaping the Competitive Herd)
- The Marketing Discovery Framework, One Like, August 2026